Wednesday, June 12, 2013

April and May 2013. Sabotage and the Economic War against Venezuela

(Shorter versions of this chronology were previously published in the blog Venezuelan Politics and Human Rights)

April 17, Maduro argues that problems of high inflation and shortages of goods are due to an “economic war” waged against the country. Claims of sabotage against the electric system have been a recurrent theme in government discourse since last year, but now claims of sabotage against the whole of the economy become more prominent. On May 10 the Agencia Venezolana de Noticias (AVN) published a note denouncing that “the foreign ultra-right and the national ultra-right (have a plan), together with private businesses, to provoke shortages of basic food products.” 

On May 11 the Minister of Agriculture, Iván Gil, declared that the government is facing “a problem of sabotage in the process of food products distribution with the purpose of destabilizing the Bolivarian government.” The same day Maduro directly accuseddirectly accused Polar industries, the biggest remaining private food industry in the country and the main producer of corn flour for the national staple arepas, of having decreased its production levels and of hoarding food stuffs. He announced that he was calling Polar´s President, Lorenzo Mendoza, to a meeting on Tuesday 14, so that he could “explain to the government why they are producing shortages (desabasteciendo).” Maduro insisted that there is an “economic war” unleashed against the country. Polar industry has repeatedly claimed that it is producing at 100% levels of its capacity. Commenting Maduro´s claims, Datanalisis´ Luís Vicente Leon wrote on twitter that “The government took over more that 50% of the productive capacity of corn flour, but now produces less that 20% of the market. Who´s responsible?” 

Lorenzo Mendoza declared on May 13 that Polar had in fact increased its productions and sales by 10% compared to the same period in 2012. Maduro ratified that there is an “economic war against the fatherland”. He specified that this war has the purpose of “producing shortages in the country, of throwing at us an uncontrolled inflation, all so that they can achieve that the country is barred from international credit (…) I say to all, we are working on a series of economic actions. We are treating this as a war plan.” To Lorenzo Mendoza he said: “If any of you think that you are going to bring down Maduro, be careful because it could be you that ends up defeated.” On May 13 Polar representatives met with Vice-President Jorge Arreaza, and Lorenzo Mendoza met the 14th with President Maduro. The meetings were cordial and Polar insisted it was producing at full capacity and willing to increase productions. The Government assured that it would also do its best to increase production or import of rice and corn to provide Polar. 

On another front of this “economic war”, on May 14 Commerce Minister Alejandro Fleming informed in a news conference that the government would be importing up to 50 million rolls of toilet paper so as to “respond to the high demand that has been generated in the country for this products, demand that has been promoted as part of the economic war waged to destabilize the country.” Fleming was referring to the hording of basic products by Venezuelan families due to rumors of shortages.


Also during this period, on April 19, Maduro claimed that his government has defeated the latest “phase of a coup d’état.” He argues that “there is no opposition in Venezuela, but only a permanent conspiracy boosted form the United States. (…) The proofs are there, some of them have come out, and we will reveal others in the next hours.” 

Tuesday, June 11, 2013

March and April 2013. Inoculated Cancer and Foreign Mercenaries

(Shorter versions of this chronology were previously published in the blog Venezuelan Politics and Human Rights  here)

These first couple of posts will bring the chronology up to date. Here I start from March 2013, right after Chávez´s passing, and close in mid-April (Presidential elections were held on April 14). The main theme of this period was the famous “inoculated cancer” theory by Maduro, according to which Chávez would have been a victim of poisoning. But also notable was the revelation by the Government of a “mercenaries plot” of central American assassins that would attempt to murder Maduro, Capriles, Cabello, and also sabotage the economy, wreck the electric grid, create food shortages , increase homicide rates, and commit random crimes against the population. 

March 5, Maduro expels two US attachés for “searching for active military personal in order to propose conspiratorial plans to them” (Aporrea)

March 5, Maduro, in the last public announcement before the passing of the President, suggests that Chávez was “inoculated” with cancer by foreign enemies. He afterwards insisted many times on this theory, originally proposed by Chávez himself when he was first diagnosed of cancer. On March 21 Maduro promised that after winning the elections, he would name a scientific commission in charge of investigating the issue.He also declares that “there are already a lot of articles on the internet on this. You only have to look them up. The Empire has created these types of experimental viruses since the 40s. They are methods of biological, bacteriological warfare.”

March 6, Maduro assures that there is a conspiracy led by Otto Reich and Roger Noriega to assassinate, not him, but the opposition candidate Capriles, with the purpose of destabilizing the government. On March 17, on a TV interview with José Vicente Rangel, Maduro insists on the existence of the plot. He announces that he has proofs of this plot and that he will make them public, but those proofs have never surfaced. Otto Reich denies the accusations.

March 20, Maduro Claims that the United States government has “ordered” the Venezuelan opposition to withdraw from the elections, generate “situations of violence”, and cry foul once the electoral results are public.

April 6, in an interview with Telesur, Foreign Minister Elias Jaua declares that “we have filtered, through our intelligence agencies, conversations from groups of the right referring to the inclusion of mercenaries from Central America in the destabilization activities in the country.”

April 5, in a meeting with supporters in Cojedes Maduro declares that the opposition “took down the electricity of all the poor areas of Aragua on Wednesday night. There is no technical justification for this, so we have dismissed the Corpoelec [State electricity company] of Aragua and he is under investigation, and all the public officials that plot against the people will go to prison.” Maduro also accuses the opposition of planning a total energy black out in the country.

April 7, during a public meeting in Guayana, Maduro denounces a plot of to kill him “generate chaos, and sabotage the electric grid”. He directly accused Armando Briquet, a top manager of the opposition campaign, of being the link between Capriles and “mercenaries sent by the right from El Salvador” that, according to Maduro, are already in Venezuela to carry out the plot. In these new plot denunciations, Maduro assures that at first he though Capriles was not directly responsible for the wide ranging conspiracies, and that he was only being duped by “sectors of the right” (indeed in the previous version of the “mercenaries plot” Capriles was considered the potential victim of assassination attempts). Now he claims to have been forced by his sources to realize that Capriles, through Briquet, is directly behind the plots.

April 8, Minister of Penitentiary Services, Iris Valera, denounces “a destabilization plan by a well-known NGO lead by someone called Humberto Prado.”  This NGO would promote violence in Venezuela´s prisons in order to “rarefy” the electoral environment of the next days.


April 8, an opposition group of students protesting for “clean elections” in Chacao is violently attacked by motorbikes wearing pro-government paraphernalia. Six students are injured. Maduro immediately orders an investigation but offers his own theory of the events: “I have been informed of violent events in the Chacao Municipality, strange violent events involving a small violent group, financed by the government of the United States.”  

This is only a monitor

This blog has a very simple purpose: to monitor conspiracy theories in Venezuelan political discourse.

There are many definitions of conspiracy theories, I subscribe to a broad and simple one: “the belief that all events are the consequence of the actions of a person or a group with evil intentions.” Since many events are indeed the consequence of actions of persons or groups, conspiracy theories sometimes turn out to be true, or not. Therefore this blog will not be about “revealing” conspiracies or “debunking” conspiracy theories.

This blog will loosely take a pragmatist perspective. I will follow as closely as possible the main threads of conspiracy theory discourse in Venezuela without assessing their truth claims. However, I will also comment from time to time on the political consequences of the use of conspiracy theories in political discourse.

Given the polarization of Venezuelan media, I cast the net wide, but when quoting government officials I usually rely on official State media (mainly from the Agencia Venezuelana de Noticias AVN, but also Venezolana de Television VTV, and the Sistema Bolivariano de Comunicación e Información SIBCI), when quoting opposition leaders I try to do it from El Universal. For opinion articles I regularly check Aporrea, Noticias24, and Noticiero Digital.

Comments and criticisms are welcome. English is not my native language so corrections and editing comments are very welcome.